One of the most common questions mortgage insurance representatives receive is, "When can mortgage insurance be removed?" It's an important question, and one that loan officers should be prepared to answer with confidence.
David Showalter, MI Education Specialist at Enact, explores the three primary paths to mortgage insurance (MI) cancellation and the role mortgage professionals can play in helping borrowers understand their options. While every loan is unique, a solid understanding of MI cancellation can help teams set realistic expectations and better strengthen your role as a trusted advisor throughout the life of the loan.
Who controls mortgage insurance cancellation?
When borrowers have mortgage insurance (specifically Borrower-Paid Mortgage Insurance or BPMI), the 1998 Homeowners Protection Act (HPA) via the CFPB establishes strict federal guidelines regarding when and how your customers’ BPMI must be removed from their mortgage.
Yet, when the time comes, borrowers often assume the mortgage insurance company controls the cancellation process. In reality, the mortgage servicer, not the MI company, determines whether cancellation requirements have been met and manages the removal process. As a reminder to your borrowers, mortgage insurance is used to insure the lender/servicer (who are the policyholders), not the borrowers themselves. Borrowers must work directly with their loan servicer to request or confirm cancellation.
Knowing this distinction can save your customers time and prevent unnecessary frustration, especially as there are three primary paths to canceling MI. Let’s help your customers understand the differences.
The three primary paths to mortgage insurance cancellation
While cancellation requirements vary by loan and servicer, there are three primary paths to mortgage insurance cancellation. Understanding how each option works can help you answer borrower questions and explain what factors may affect eligibility.
1. Automatic Termination Based on Original Value
The most common method of cancellation is automatic termination.
Every mortgage follows an amortization schedule that projects when the loan balance will reach 78% of the property's original value (based on the lower of the original purchase price or appraised value).
When that threshold is reached, the servicer is generally required by the Homeowners Protection Act to automatically terminate borrower-paid mortgage insurance, provided the loan meets applicable requirements. The loan must be current, and no payment history, evidence of value, or seasoning is required.
For borrowers who simply continue making their scheduled payments, this is the easiest and most predictable path to cancellation.
2. Borrower Requested Cancellation Through Actual Payments
Borrowers don't have to wait for the scheduled amortization date if they reduce their principal balance more quickly.
Whether through a lump-sum payment or by making additional principal payments over time, borrowers may request cancellation once the loan balance reaches 80% of the original value (again, based on the lower of the original purchase price or appraised value).
The Homeowners Protection Act provides this option based on actual payments. In addition to reaching 80%, there are other requirements such as a good payment history, the loan is current, no subordinate liens, and the servicer may require verification that the property's value has not declined, which could include a full appraisal.
Meeting the loan-to-value requirement is only part of the equation. Borrowers should always consult their servicer to understand the specific documentation that will be required.
3. Borrower Requested Cancellation Based on Current Property Value
The third method is cancellation based on the home's current market value. This option is not provided by the Homeowners Protection Act, but is offered by Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, and other investors.
This option became much more common following the rapid home appreciation experienced during and after the COVID-era housing market.
Under current Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac servicing guidelines, borrowers generally must wait at least two years before pursuing cancellation based on an increase in property value alone. In most cases, the servicer will require the borrower to obtain and pay for a new appraisal. Please note that GSE guidelines say the servicer must verify the property value using a valuation method in their guidelines. It may not be an appraisal.
General servicing guidelines include:
- After two years: The loan balance must be 75% or less of the current appraised value.
- After five years: The loan balance must be 80% or less of the current appraised value.
There is one important exception. If the borrower has made significant improvements that materially increase the home's value, such as adding livable square footage, the required waiting period may be shortened.
It's important to distinguish significant improvements from cosmetic upgrades. New paint, flooring, or carpeting generally do not qualify. Structural improvements that add meaningful value are much more likely to satisfy servicing requirements.
Help borrowers plan ahead for MI cancellation
Whether a borrower hopes to remove their mortgage insurance through accelerated principal repayment or increased property value, the best first step is to contact their loan servicer early in the process.
The servicer can explain its specific requirements, identify accepted valuation methods, and clarify which improvements may qualify when determining eligibility for cancellation. Having these conversations before spending time or money on appraisals or home projects can help borrowers avoid surprises and better understand their options. LTV isn't the only factor when cancelling MI based on current value. Check your investor's guidelines for additional requirements, such as payment history, loan status, and acceptable evidence of value.
>> Looking to strengthen your mortgage insurance expertise even further? Explore more insights from David Showalter and continue building a deeper understanding of MI fundamentals.
From product structures to strategic positioning, knowing the basics, and beyond, can help you better support borrowers, strengthen partnerships, and stay competitive in any market cycle.
Get more from your MI partnership
If you'd like to better understand mortgage insurance cancellation guidelines, or if you'd like training on this or other mortgage insurance strategies that can help you better serve borrowers, reach out to your local Enact Sales representative.
And, we have more resources ready for you and your borrowers – access our MI Cancellation materials here (which even includes a Borrower-facing flier). For more about BPMI cancellation, dive into our Discover360℠ article on the topic.
This also contains an Enact Training course on MI Cancellation and Termination. Access it here to get even more in-depth information on HPA 1998, CFPB Bulletin, termination procedures, initial/ annual disclosures, and more!
Don’t forget about the suite of tools we always offer, including Rate Express®, Underwriting Resources, and other training resources to further help you along the mortgage origination journey.
Source: David Showalter is a MI Education Specialist at Enact Mortgage Insurance who works closely with lenders and loan officers to support effective MI strategies and borrower education.
The statements in this article are solely the opinions of David Showalter and do not necessarily reflect the views of Enact or its management. Opinions expressed are for educational purposes only. Always review current, applicable agency guidelines and consult your compliance and legal advisors when borrowers reach out to discuss MI cancellation.
Never miss a post by subscribing to Enact MI's Discover360℠ Blog! We’ll send you our most up-to-date topics right into your inbox.
