In today’s lending environment, efficiency is essential. Yet many lenders still lose valuable time navigating avoidable conditions, re-runs, recalculations, and exceptions. A major source of friction… Not fully knowing the nuanced differences between Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.
Despite how similar the two GSEs may appear, their guidelines diverge in critical areas—from LTV limits and DTI calculations to treatment of income, reserves, assets, and more. When mortgage teams overlook these subtleties, the result is often restructuring, delays, or missed opportunities for your borrowers’ advantage.
This article is designed to solve that problem. Brought to you through the expertise of Mary Kay Scully, Director of Customer Education at Enact, this guide breaks down why staying educated on GSE distinctions matters, and how your operational efficiency, borrower experience, and profitability all stand to benefit.
Guideline differences that cost time, money, and certainty
For many lending teams, choosing which GSE to run a file through defaults to habit, assumption, or software preference. But failing to strategically select between Desktop Underwriter® and Loan Product Advisor® can create:
- Unnecessary documentation requests
- Higher reserve or LTV requirements
- Overly restrictive treatment of debt or income
- Incorrect assumptions about rental income, cash‑out, or self‑employment rules
- Reduced borrower eligibility
Even a small misalignment, like how each GSE calculates DTI, handles disputed tradelines, or defines cash‑out, can materially affect loan structure.
The cost of not knowing these differences?
Time lost, conditions added, and loans reworked.
What happens when you overlook GSE distinctions
Without a clear understanding of guideline differences, mortgage professionals face:
1. Slower Processing and More Suspense Conditions
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac vary on how they assess DTI, treat collection accounts, calculate rental income, and document assets. Missing these distinctions forces time‑consuming backtracking.
2. Eligibility Shifts Late in the Process
Differences in maximum LTV/ CLTV/ HCLTV by occupancy and property type can shift eligibility entirely depending on the GSE you select.
3. Missed Opportunities for Strategic Structuring
Some policies, like Fannie Mae’s unique Student Loan Cash‑Out Refinance option, exist only on one side of the GSE equation.
4. Borrower Experience Friction
Uncertainty or re‑runs create confused borrowers and stressed teams, particularly in fast‑moving purchase markets.
5. Operational Inefficiency Across Teams
Process breakdowns then ripple across loan officers, processors, underwriters, QC, and secondary.
The reality is lost time and possibly incorrect loan structuring by not knowing which GSE to select, when both are an option. It’s crucial to not overlook Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac guideline distinctions.
Conquer the differences to strengthen your structuring strategy
Understanding where Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac differ empowers lenders to reduce friction, maximize borrower opportunity, and proactively structure stronger files. Below is a simplified breakdown of key guideline differences that can help get you started.
GSE LTV and Property Type Differences Explained
LTV Variances by Occupancy & Property Type
While both GSEs allow up to 97% LTV on certain primary 1‑unit purchases, limits shift differently for ARMs, 2–4 unit properties, investment transactions, and cash‑out refinances. Freddie Mac often mirrors Fannie Mae’s caps, but not always identically.
For example:
- Investment properties: Both cap cash‑out at 75% on 1‑unit, but Freddie aligns closely on refinances for 2–4 unit properties.
- Second homes: Both hold at 90% for purchase, with identical cash‑out caps.
DTI, Credit, and Liability Treatment: Fannie vs. Freddie
- Fannie Mae caps DTI at 50% and calculates to two decimal places.
- Freddie Mac does not publish a maximum and rounds DTI down.
Other differences include:
- Collection account treatment
- Handling of disputed tradelines
- Alimony calculations (Freddie subtracts from income; Fannie allows flexibility)
- Student loan treatment, especially for deferred/ IBR loans
Asset, Reserve, Gift, and Business Funds: Key Variances
Examples include:
- Freddie Mac’s more prescriptive documentation for business asset use
- Different rules for wedding gifts or graduation gifts
- Reserve calculations tied to UPB (Fannie) vs. PITIA (Freddie)
- Varying standards on verification periods
Income Differences: Variable, Hourly, and Self-Employment
- Fannie Mae: Allows variable income with 12–24 months if offsetting factors are present
- Freddie Mac: Requires minimum 12 months for fluctuating hourly income and applies income‑trend analysis thresholds
Self‑employment documentation timelines also differ based on longevity and qualifying structure.
Rental Income & Multiple Financed Properties Rules
- Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac allow rental income use only with documented primary housing expense.
- For borrowers with 7–10 financed properties, both require stronger credit and reserves, but calculations differ.
This list is not comprehensive, but helps you identify and get ready for specific themes and attributes you need to consider as you originate your mortgage loans. For more information and the most up-to-date guidance, see the Fannie Mae selling guide and Freddie Mac selling guide on their sites. And for an in-depth summary of key differences not covered in this article, check out our Training Course on Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac: Understanding Your Options anytime – the recorded webinar is available to you on-demand.
Better structuring leads to better results
When loan teams understand these distinctions, the benefits are immediate:
- More confident file selection (DU vs. LPA)
- Faster, cleaner approvals
- Reduced suspense and conditions
- Higher borrower satisfaction
- Operational lift across origination, processing, and underwriting
- A measurable competitive advantage
This is why ongoing education isn’t optional, it’s a strategic driver that elevates the entire loan manufacturing process.
More ways we at Enact can help
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac: Understanding Your Options
Go deeper into these differences with the course that inspired this guide. Strengthen your structuring strategies, sharpen your guideline awareness, and empower your team to deliver smarter, faster lending decisions. Available as a recording, on-demand when you need it. Register here today >>
We are here to help you navigate evolving GSE guidelines with clarity and confidence. Stay ahead of GSE changes and updates with Enact’s suite of tools—including Rate Express®, Underwriting Resources, and other training resources to further help you along the mortgage origination journey. Plus, you can always reach out to your Enact Sales Representative if you need an extra helping hand.
Source: Mary Kay Scully is the Director of Customer Education at Enact Mortgage Insurance with over 30 years of industry experience. She trains over 35,000 mortgage professionals annually on topics including tax return review, fraud detection, process improvements, and compliance.
The statements in this article are solely the opinions of Mary Kay Scully and do not necessarily reflect the views of Enact or its management. Opinions expressed are for educational purposes only. GSE guidelines are subject to change. Always review current agency publications and consult your compliance and legal advisors.
Never miss a post by subscribing to the Enact MI Blog! We’ll send you our most up-to-date topics right into your inbox.
